AVANALE WATER SOLUTIONS Developing Partnerships through support and quality products

Membrane Equivalence Table

Avanale Water Solutions — wholesalers to the water treatment industry

AVRO® membrane cross-reference

Find the AVRO® reverse osmosis element that corresponds to a DuPont, Hydranautics or Toray membrane, in 4″ and 8″. Equivalences are indicative and compiled to the best of our knowledge from publicly available manufacturer data sheets. Test conditions vary between brands — see the notes at the foot of this page.

Equivalent elements at a glance

The nearest published equivalent by brand. Performance figures for each group are in the technical comparison below.

4″ elements (4040)

Avanale

DuPont

Hydranautics

Toray

AVRO-XLP-4040

XLE-4040

ESPA4-LD-4040

TMH10A

AVRO-ULP-4040MR-2

LC LE-4040

AVRO-ULP-4040HF

ESPA1-LD-4040

AVRO-ES-4040UFR

ESPA2-LD-4040

AVRO-BW-4040

CPA2-4040

TM710

AVROXL-4040FR

TW30-4040, BW30-4040

TML10F

 

8″ elements (8040)

Avanale

DuPont

Hydranautics

Toray

AVRO-ULP-8040HF

BW30HRLE-440, LE-400

ESPA1

AVRO-ES-8040UFR

ESPA2-LD

AVRO-BW-8040

BW30-400

CPA3

TM720-400

AVROXL-400FR

BW30XFR-400/34

CPA5-LD

TM720D-400

AVRO-EP-8040FR

BW30XFR-400/34

CPA5-LD

TM720D-400

AVRO-EP-8040HRLE

BW30HR-440i

AVRO-ZM-8040LP

PROC10

TML20D-400

AVRO-SW-8040HF

SW30HRLE-440i, SW30XLE-400, SW30HRLE-400

TM820V-400

AVRO-SW-8040FR

SW30XFR-400/34

SWC5-LD

AVRO-SW-8040XHF

SW30ULE-440

 

A cross-reference is a starting point, not a design. Element performance depends on your feed water, temperature and recovery. 

 

Run a projection on your own duty using the AVRO membrane projection tool.

 

Technical comparison

Each manufacturer’s published performance data, grouped by AVRO® element. Figures are measured under each manufacturer’s own test conditions, shown in the final column.

4″ elements (4040)

Extra low pressure — AVRO-XLP-4040

Element

Active area ft² (m²)

Permeate flow GPD (m³/d)

Stabilised rejection %

Minimum rejection %

Feed spacer (mil)

Test conditions

AVRO-XLP-4040

Avanale

90 (8.4)

2,600 (9.8)

99.2

99.0

28

100 psi, 500 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 7.5–8

XLE-4040

DuPont

87 (8.1)

2,600 (9.8)

99.0

28

100 psi, 500 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 8

ESPA4-LD-4040

Hydranautics

80 (7.4)

2,350 (8.9)

99.2

99.0

34

100 psi, 500 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 6.5–7

TMH10A

Toray

87 (8.1)

2,400 (9.1)

99.3

99.0

31

100 psi, 500 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 7

 

Ultra low pressure — AVRO-ULP-4040MR-2

Element

Active area ft² (m²)

Permeate flow GPD (m³/d)

Stabilised rejection %

Minimum rejection %

Feed spacer (mil)

Test conditions

AVRO-ULP-4040MR-2

Avanale

100 (9.3)

2,400 (9.1)

99.6

99.5

28

150 psi, 1500 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 7.5–8

LC LE-4040

DuPont

94 (8.7)

2,500 (9.5)

99.2

99.1

28

125 psi, 2000 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 8

 

Ultra low pressure, high flow — AVRO-ULP-4040HF

Element

Active area ft² (m²)

Permeate flow GPD (m³/d)

Stabilised rejection %

Minimum rejection %

Feed spacer (mil)

Test conditions

AVRO-ULP-4040HF

Avanale

100 (9.3)

2,700 (10.2)

99.5

99.4

28

150 psi, 1500 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 7.5–8

ESPA1-LD-4040

Hydranautics

80 (7.4)

2,450 (9.3)

99.4

99.2

34

150 psi, 1500 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 6.5–7

 

Energy saving — AVRO-ES-4040UFR

Element

Active area ft² (m²)

Permeate flow GPD (m³/d)

Stabilised rejection %

Minimum rejection %

Feed spacer (mil)

Test conditions

AVRO-ES-4040UFR

Avanale

85 (7.9)

2,200 (8.3)

99.6

99.5

34

150 psi, 2000 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 7.5–8

ESPA2-LD-4040

Hydranautics

80 (7.43)

2,000 (7.57)

99.6

99.4

34

150 psi, 1500 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 7

 

Brackish water — AVRO-BW-4040

Element

Active area ft² (m²)

Permeate flow GPD (m³/d)

Stabilised rejection %

Minimum rejection %

Feed spacer (mil)

Test conditions

AVRO-BW-4040

Avanale

85 (7.9)

2,500 (9.5)

99.6

99.5

28

225 psi, 2000 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 7.5–8

CPA2-4040

Hydranautics

85 (7.9)

2,250 (8.5)

99.5

99.2

28

225 psi, 1500 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 6.5–7

TM710

Toray

87 (8.0)

2,400 (9.1)

99.7

99.0

31

225 psi, 2000 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 7

 

Fouling resistant — AVROXL-4040FR

Element

Active area ft² (m²)

Permeate flow GPD (m³/d)

Stabilised rejection %

Minimum rejection %

Feed spacer (mil)

Test conditions

AVROXL-4040FR

Avanale

85 (7.9)

2,300 (8.7)

99.6

99.5

34

225 psi, 2000 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 7.5–8

TW30-4040

DuPont

78 (7.2)

2,400 (9.1)

99.5

98.0

34

225 psi, 2000 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 8

BW30-4040

DuPont

78 (7.2)

2,400 (9.1)

99.5

98.0

34

225 psi, 2000 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 8

TML10F

Toray

87 (8.1)

2,200 (8.3)

99.7

99.0

31

225 psi, 2000 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 7

 

8″ elements (8040)

Ultra low pressure, high flow — AVRO-ULP-8040HF

Element

Active area ft² (m²)

Permeate flow GPD (m³/d)

Stabilised rejection %

Minimum rejection %

Feed spacer (mil)

Test conditions

AVRO-ULP-8040HF

Avanale

440 (40.9)

12,500 (47.3)

99.5

99.4

28

150 psi, 1500 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 7.5–8

BW30HRLE-440

DuPont

440 (40.9)

12,650 (47.9)

99.3

99.1

28

150 psi, 2000 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 8

LE-400

DuPont

400 (37.2)

12,200 (46.0)

99.3

99.0

28

150 psi, 2000 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 8

ESPA1

Hydranautics

400 (37.2)

12,000 (45.4)

99.4

99.2

28

150 psi, 1500 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 6.5–7

 

Energy saving — AVRO-ES-8040UFR

Element

Active area ft² (m²)

Permeate flow GPD (m³/d)

Stabilised rejection %

Minimum rejection %

Feed spacer (mil)

Test conditions

AVRO-ES-8040UFR

Avanale

400 (37.2)

10,500 (39.7)

99.6

99.5

34

150 psi, 2000 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 7.5–8

ESPA2-LD

Hydranautics

400 (37.2)

10,000 (37.9)

99.6

99.5

34

150 psi, 1500 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 6.5–7

 

Brackish water — AVRO-BW-8040

Element

Active area ft² (m²)

Permeate flow GPD (m³/d)

Stabilised rejection %

Minimum rejection %

Feed spacer (mil)

Test conditions

AVRO-BW-8040

Avanale

400 (37.2)

10,500 (39.7)

99.7

99.6

28

225 psi, 2000 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 7.5–8

BW30-400

DuPont

400 (37.2)

10,500 (39.7)

99.5

99.0

28

225 psi, 2000 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 8

CPA3

Hydranautics

400 (37.2)

11,000 (41.6)

99.7

99.6

34

225 psi, 1500 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 6.5–7

TM720-400

Toray

400 (37.2)

10,200 (38.6)

99.7

99.0

31

225 psi, 2000 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 7

 

Fouling resistant — AVROXL-400FR and AVRO-EP-8040FR

Element

Active area ft² (m²)

Permeate flow GPD (m³/d)

Stabilised rejection %

Minimum rejection %

Feed spacer (mil)

Test conditions

AVROXL-400FR

Avanale

400 (37.2)

11,500 (43.5)

99.75

99.65

34

225 psi (15.5 bar), 2000 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 7.5–8

AVRO-EP-8040FR

Avanale

400 (37.2)

10,500 (39.7)

99.75

99.65

34-LD

225 psi (15.5 bar), 2000 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 7.5–8

BW30XFR-400/34

DuPont

400 (37.2)

11,500 (43.5)

99.65

99.4

34-LDP

225 psi, 2000 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 8

CPA5-LD

Hydranautics

400 (37.2)

11,000 (41.6)

99.7

99.5

34

225 psi, 1500 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 6.5–7

TM720D-400

Toray

400 (37.2)

11,000 (41.6)

99.8

99.65

34

225 psi, 2000 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 7

 

High rejection, low energy — AVRO-EP-8040HRLE

Element

Active area ft² (m²)

Permeate flow GPD (m³/d)

Stabilised rejection %

Minimum rejection %

Feed spacer (mil)

Test conditions

AVRO-EP-8040HRLE

Avanale

440 (40.9)

13,000 (49.2)

99.7

99.5

28

2000 ppm NaCl, 225 psi, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 7.5–8

BW30HR-440i

DuPont

440 (41)

12,650 (48)

99.7

99.4

28

2000 ppm NaCl, 225 psi, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 8

 

Low pressure, high rejection — AVRO-ZM-8040LP

Element

Active area ft² (m²)

Permeate flow GPD (m³/d)

Stabilised rejection %

Minimum rejection %

Feed spacer (mil)

Test conditions

AVRO-ZM-8040LP

Avanale

400 (37.2)

10,000 (37.8)

99.8

99.7

34-LD

225 psi (15.5 bar), 2000 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 7.5–8

PROC10

Hydranautics

400 (37.2)

10,500 (39.7)

99.8

99.7

34

225 psi, 2000 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 6.5–7

TML20D-400

Toray

400 (37.2)

10,500 (39.7)

99.8

99.65

34

225 psi, 2000 mg/L NaCl, 15% recovery, 25°C, pH 7

 

Seawater, high flow — AVRO-SW-8040HF

Element

Active area ft² (m²)

Permeate flow GPD (m³/d)

Stabilised rejection %

Minimum rejection %

Boron rejection %

Feed spacer (mil)

Test conditions

AVRO-SW-8040HF

Avanale

400 (37.2)

9,000 (34.1)

99.85

99.75

92

28

32,000 ppm NaCl, 5 ppm boron, 800 psi, 8% recovery, 25°C, pH 7.5–8

SW30HRLE-440i

DuPont

440 (41)

8,000 (30.2)

99.8

99.65

92

28

32,000 ppm NaCl, 5 ppm boron, 800 psi, 8% recovery, 25°C, pH 8

SW30XLE-400

DuPont

400 (37.2)

9,000 (34.1)

99.8

99.6

91.5

28

32,000 ppm NaCl, 5 ppm boron, 800 psi, 8% recovery, 25°C, pH 8

SW30HRLE-400

DuPont

400 (37.2)

7,500 (28)

99.8

99.65

92

28

32,000 ppm NaCl, 5 ppm boron, 800 psi, 8% recovery, 25°C, pH 8

TM820V-400

Toray

400 (37.2)

9,000 (34.1)

99.8

99.5

99.8

28

800 psi, 32,000 mg/L NaCl, 8% recovery, 25°C, pH 7

 

Seawater, fouling resistant — AVRO-SW-8040FR

Element

Active area ft² (m²)

Permeate flow GPD (m³/d)

Stabilised rejection %

Minimum rejection %

Boron rejection %

Feed spacer (mil)

Test conditions

AVRO-SW-8040FR

Avanale

400 (37.2)

9,000 (34.1)

99.85

99.75

92

34-LD

32,000 ppm NaCl, 5 ppm boron, 800 psi, 8% recovery, 25°C, pH 7.5–8

SW30XFR-400/34

DuPont

400 (37)

7,500 (28)

99.8

99.65

92

34

32,000 ppm NaCl, 5 ppm boron, 800 psi, 8% recovery, 25°C, pH 8

SWC5-LD

Hydranautics

400 (37.2)

9,000 (34.1)

99.8

99.7

99.8

34

800 psi (55 bar), 32,000 mg/L NaCl, 10% recovery, 25°C, pH 6.5–7

 

Seawater, extra high flow — AVRO-SW-8040XHF

Element

Active area ft² (m²)

Permeate flow GPD (m³/d)

Stabilised rejection %

Minimum rejection %

Boron rejection %

Feed spacer (mil)

Test conditions

AVRO-SW-8040XHF

Avanale

440 (40.9)

12,500 (47.3)

99.7

99.6

28

32,000 ppm NaCl, 800 psi, 8% recovery, 25°C, pH 7.5–8

SW30ULE-440

DuPont

440 (41)

12,000 (45.4)

99.7

99.55

28

32,000 ppm NaCl, 800 psi, 8% recovery, 25°C, pH 8

 

About this comparison

The equivalences shown are indicative only and have been compiled to the best of our knowledge from manufacturers’ publicly available product data sheets. Performance figures are each manufacturer’s own published data, measured under that manufacturer’s stated test conditions, which vary between brands — feed concentration, pressure, pH and recovery are not uniform across the tables. Figures should therefore be read as a guide rather than as a like-for-like measurement.

This is not a complete listing. Some competitor membranes will not appear. Where a cell is blank, no equivalent was identified in the data sheets used to compile this table — it does not mean no comparable element exists. If the element you are replacing is not shown, contact us and we will identify the closest match.

Data sheets are revised from time to time and specifications may change without notice. This table is a selection guide and does not form part of any offer or warranty. Element performance depends on feed water quality, temperature, recovery and system configuration, none of which are reflected in a cross-reference. To size a system properly, run a projection using the AVRO® membrane projection tool available on this site, or contact us to discuss your duty.

AVRO is a registered trade mark of Avanale Enterprises Pty Ltd. Product names and model numbers of other manufacturers are the trade marks of their respective owners and are used here for identification and comparison purposes only. Avanale Water Solutions is not affiliated with, authorised by or endorsed by any of those manufacturers.